one of the effective ways to ensure the state protection of employees of the penal system and their relatives is the application of security measures provided for in art. 5 of the Federal law «on State Protection of Judges, officials of law enforcement and Control authorities».
the use of security measures in the form of arms and special means is most expedient for the staff of the penal service since they possess the service weapon, special means and have the skills to use them.
the analysis of certain provisions of this law and the procedure for issuing weapons to persons subject to state protection, which is a close person of the officer of the penal system, showed the existence of contradictions between them in the absence of powers of the bodies and institutions of the Federal Penal Service of russia to extradite weapons to protected persons. to eliminate the revealed contradiction it is proposed to include in the appropriate order the bodies and institutions of the penal system.
another legal gap was revealed in the course of analysis of the grounds for the use of physical force, weapons, special means by the staff of the penal system. the legislator defined the boundaries within which the right to use weapons, special means and physical force can be realized, namely the territory of correctional facilities and remand centers. however law enforcement practice shows that ensuring the personal safety of the protected person must be guaranteed outside the territories of institutions too. In order to eliminate the corresponding contradiction it is necessary to amend art. 28 of the law «on institutions and bodies that carry out criminal penalties in the form of deprivation of liberty» to expand the limits of the use of weapons, special means and physical force outside the territories of institutions in the event of the implementation of security measures against the protected person.
Senior Lecturer of the Department of Administrative and
Legal Disciplines of the Vologda Institute of Law and Economics of the Federal
Penal Service of Russia
, e-mail email@example.com
1. galahov S. S. Pravovye i prikladnye problemy primeneniya mer bezopasnosti v territorial’nyh organah FSIn rossii [legal and applied Problems of application of Security Measures in territorial Bodies of the Federal Penal Service of russia]. Deyatel’nost’ organov vnutrennih del po obespecheniyu bezopasnosti lic, podlezhashchih gosudarstvennoj zashchite v sovremennyh usloviyah: voprosy teorii i praktiki – the activities of the internal affairs bodies to ensure the safety of persons subject to state protection in modern conditions: theory and practice. 2015. Iss. 2. P. 30–37. (In russ.).
2. ob uchrezhdeniyah i organah, ispolnyayushchih ugolovnye nakazaniya v vide lisheniya svobody : zakon ros. Federacii ot 21.07.1993 № 5473-1 [on institutions and bodies that carry out criminal penalties in the form of deprivation of liberty: law of the russian Federation from 21.07.1993 no. 5473-1]. Vedomosti S»ezda narodnyh deputatov i Verhovnogo Soveta ros. Federacii – gazette of the Congress of People’s Deputies and the Supreme Council of the russian Federation. 1993. Iss.
33. art. 1316. (In russ.).
3. o nedostatkah v organizacii rezhima i obespechenii nadzora za podozrevaemymi, obvinyaemymi i osuzhdennymi v ispravitel’nyh uchrezhdeniyah i sledstvennyh izolyatorah v 2017 godu : inform. pis’mo FSIn rossii ot 26.02.2018 iskh.
№ 03-12891 [on the shortcomings in the organization of the regime and the provision of supervision of the suspects, accused and convicted in prisons and pre-trial detention centers in 2017 : information letter of the Federal Penal Service of russia from 26.02.2018 no. 03-12891]. Dokument opublikovan ne byl – the document was not published. (In russ.).
4. Karimova g. yu., Malikova n. V. Pravovoe regulirovanie vydachi oruzhiya kak mery bezopasnosti, primenyaemoj v otnoshenii sudej, dolzhnostnyh lic pravoohranitel’nyh i kontroliruyushchih organov [legal regulation of the issue of arms as a security measure applied to judges, law enforcement and regulatory officials]. rossijskij sud’ya – the russian judge. 2013. Iss. 13. P. 37–40. (In russ.).
5. Majstrenko g. a. Bezopasnost’ sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy kak gosudarstvennaya forma zashchity i puti ee resheniya [Safety of the staff of the penal system as a state form of protection and ways to solve it]. rossijskij sledovatel’
– russian Investigator. 2016. Iss. 6. P. 43–45. (In russ.).
6. Pilipenko V. g., Devyashin D. g. Pravovye osnovy obespecheniya lichnoj bezopasnosti sotrudnika ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy ; ucheb. posobie [the legal basis for ensuring the personal safety of the officer of the penal system : tutorial]. tomsk, 2014. (In russ.).
7. o poryadke vydachi oruzhiya licam, podlezhashchim gosudarstvennoj zashchite : postanovlenie Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 17.07.1996 № 831 [on the procedure for issuing weapons to persons subject to state protection: Decree of the government of the russian Federation from 17.07.1996 no. 831]. Sobr. zakonodatel’stva ros. Federacii – Collection of legislation of the russian Federation. 1996. Iss. 31. art. 3723. (In russ.).
8. ob utverzhdenii instrukcii o poryadke postoyannogo nosheniya i hraneniya boevogo ognestrel’nogooruzhiya, boepripasov i special’nyh sredstv sotrudnikami ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy : prikaz FSIn rossii ot 11.05.2006 № 223 [on approval of the instruction on the procedure for the permanent carrying and storage of firearms, ammunition and special means by the officers of the penal system : the order of the FSIn of russia as of 11.05.2006 no. 223]. Vedomosti ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy – Journal of the penal system. 2008. Iss. 6. (In russ.).
9. Starostin S. a. Problemyproizvodstvapoadministrativnymdelamobadministrativnomnadzorezalicami, osvobozhdennymi iz mest lisheniya svobody [Problems of production in administrative cases on administrative supervision of persons released from places of deprivation of liberty]. Vestnik instituta: prestuplenie, nakazanie, ispravlenie – Bulletin of the Institute: crime, punishment, correction. 2015. Iss. 4 (32). P. 16–19. (In russ.).
10. o gosudarstvennoj zashchite sudej, dolzhnostnyh lic pravoohranitel’nyh i kontroliruyushchih organov : feder. zakon ot 20.04.1996 № 45-FZ [on the State Protection of Judges, officials of law enforcement and Supervisory Bodies: Federal law from 20.04.1996 no. 45-Fl]. ros. gaz. – the russian newspaper. 1995. april 26. (In russ.).