Journal section JURISPRUDENCE
Legal problems of pension provision for persons who served in bodies and institutions of the penal system and their families
the article presents a scientific analysis of some problems of legal regulation of pension provision for persons who served in institutions and bodies of the penal system and their family members; the experience of solving these problems in the legislation of the republic of Belarus is given; proposals are formulated to improve legislation and law enforcement activities aimed at raising the level of social and legal protection for employees of the Federal Penal Service. among the basic principles of improving legislation in the field of legal regulation the following are highlighted: ensuring the social security of employees, encouraging them to become attached to the service and serving the job, combined with economic incentives for deferred retirement; the establishment of a unified approach to the procedure for calculating the length of service for years and of monetary allowances for the purpose of a pension on the one hand, and taking into account the specifics of the service in the penal system and its various divisions, on the other hand; regulation of issues of pension provision for persons who served in institutions and bodies of the penal system, at the legislative level within the framework of a special law, excluding duplication of legal norms in other legislative acts; ensuring the validity and objectivity of the legislative changes introduced.
Keywords: penal system; law enforcement service; social protection; legal protection; pension provision.
-
Professor of the Department of administrative and legal Disciplines of the Vologda Institute of law and economics of the Federal Penal Service of russia, PhD. in law, associate Professor
ORCID 0000-0002-2747-9723
, e-mail pl-family@yandex.ru
1. aniskina n. V. reformirovanie sistemy pensionnogo obespecheniya sotrudnikov uIS: rossijskij i zarubezhnyj opyt [reforming the pension system of the penitentiary system staff: russian and foreign experience]. ugolovno-ispolnitel’naya sistema na sovremennom ehtape: vzaimodejstvie nauki i praktiki : materialy mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. mezhvedomstv. konf. (g. Samara, 16–17 iyunya 2016 g.) – Penal system at the present stage: interaction of science and practice : materials of the international scientific and practical interdepartmental conference (Samara, June 16–17, 2016). Samara, 2016. P. 20–23. (In russ.).
2. Demin V. M. Profilaktika pravonarushenij sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy : avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Prevention of offenses committed by employees of the penal system : the author’s abstract of the diss. ... PhD. in law]. Moscow, 2007. 26 p. (In russ.).
3. Ivanova V. V., Sokolov n. a. aktual’nye voprosy pensionnogo obespecheniya sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy [topical issues of pension provision for employees of the penitentiary system]. aktual’nye voprosy kadrovoj raboty, social’noj i pravovoj zashchity sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy rossii : sb. materialov nauch.-prakt. seminara (g. Vologda, 17 aprelya 2017 g.) – actual issues of personnel work, social and legal protection of the staff of the russian penal system : a collection of materials of the scientific and practical seminar (Vologda, april 17, 2017). Vologda, 2017. P. 71–75. (In russ.).
4. Muhtarova e. a. Social’naya zashchita sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy [Social protection of the penitentiary system staff]. aktual’nye voprosy kadrovoj raboty, social’noj i pravovoj zashchity sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy rossii : sb. materialov nauch.-prakt. seminara (g. Vologda, 17 aprelya 2017 g.) – actual issues of personnel work, social and legal protection of the staff of the russian penal system : a collection of materials of the scientific and practical seminar (Vologda, april 17, 2017). Vologda, 2017. P. 102–109. (In russ.).
5. o vnesenii proekta federal’nogo zakona «o sluzhbe v ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sisteme rossijskoj Federacii» : pis’mo Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 01.02.2018 № 845p-P4 [on the Introduction of the Draft Federal law «on Service in the Penitentiary System of the russian Federation» : a letter by the government of the russian Federation from 01.02.2018 no. 845p-P4]. availabel at: https://legal.report/uploads/doc/2/379630-7_02022018_0120032836-1.pdf (accessed 20.03.2018). (In russ.).
6. o pensionnom obespechenii voennosluzhashchih, lic nachal’stvuyushchego i ryadovogo sostava organov vnutrennih del, Sledstvennogo komiteta respubliki Belarus’, gosudarstvennogo komiteta sudebnyh ehkspertiz respubliki Belarus’, organov i podrazdelenij po chrezvychajnym situaciyam i organov finansovyh rassledovanij : zakon respubliki Belarus’ ot 17.12.1992 № 2050-XII (red. ot 09.01.2017, s izm. ot 31.12.2017) [on pension provision for servicemen, officers and officers of the internal affairs bodies, the Investigative Committee of the republic of Belarus, the State Committee of Forensic expertise of the republic of Belarus, emergency agencies and units and financial investigation bodies : law of the republic of Belarus from 17.12.1992 no. 2050-XII (in red. on 09.01.2017, as amended on 31.12.2017). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
7. o pensionnom obespechenii lic, prohodivshih voennuyu sluzhbu, sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe, organah po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskih sredstv i psihotropnyh veshchestv, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, vojskah nacional’noj gvardii rossijskoj Federacii, i ih semej : zakon ros. Federacii ot 12.02.1993 № 4468-1 (red. ot 01.07.2017) [on the provision of pensions for persons who have completed military service, service in the internal affairs agencies, the State Fire Service, the bodies responsible for controlling the circulation of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, institutions and bodies of the penal system, the troops of the national guard of the russian Federation, and their families : the law of russian Federation from 12.02.1993 no. 4468-1 (in red. on 01.07.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
8. o poryadke ischisleniya vyslugi let, naznacheniya i vyplaty pensij i posobij voennosluzhashchim oficerskogo sostava, praporshchikam, michmanam, serzhantam i starshinam, soldatam i matrosam, prohodyashchim voennuyu sluzhbu po kontraktu, licam nachal’stvuyushchego i ryadovogo sostava Sledstvennogo komiteta, gosudarstvennogo komiteta sudebnyh ehkspertiz, organov vnutrennih del, organov i podrazdelenij po chrezvychajnym situaciyam, organov finansovyh rassledovanij i chlenam ih semej : postanovlenie Soveta ministrov respubliki Belarus’ ot 05.07.1993
№ 432 (v red. ot 04.10.2017) [on the procedure for calculating the length of service, the appointment and payment of pensions and allowances to military officers of the officer corps, warrant officers, sergeants, soldiers and sailors of military service under contract, officers of the Investigative Committee, the State Committee of Forensic expertise, bodies Ministry of Internal affairs, bodies and departments for emergency situations, financial investigation bodies and members of their families: resolution of the Council of Ministers of the republic of Belarus from 05.07.1993 no. 432 (in red. on 04.10.2017)]. availabel at: https://base.spinform.ru/show_doc.fwx?rgn=23776 (accessed 01.02.2018). (In russ.).
9. o poryadke ischisleniya vyslugi let, naznacheniya i vyplaty pensij, kompensacij i posobij licam, prohodivshim voennuyu sluzhbu v kachestve oficerov, praporshchikov, michmanov i voennosluzhashchih sverhsrochnoj sluzhby ili po kontraktu v kachestve soldat, matrosov, serzhantov i starshin libo sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, federal’noj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhby, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, vojskah nacional’noj gvardii rossijskoj Federacii, i ih sem’yam v rossijskoj Federacii : postanovlenie Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 22.09.1993 № 941 (red. ot 16.08.2017) [on the procedure for calculating the length of service, the appointment and payment of pensions, compensation and benefits to persons who have served as officers, ensigns, warrant officers and servicemen of extra-long service or as contract soldiers, sailors, sergeants and foremen, or service in internal affairs bodies, the federal fire service of the State Fire Service, the institutions and bodies of the penal system, the troops of the national guard of the russian Federation, and their families in the russian Federation : decree russian Federation from 22.09.1993 no. 941 (in red. on 16.08.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
10. o sluzhbe v organah vnutrennih del rossijskoj Federacii i vnesenii izmenenij v otdel’nye zakonodatel’nye akty rossijskoj Federacii : feder. zakon ot 30.11.2011 № 342-FZ (red. ot 01.07.2017) [on the service in the internal affairs bodies of the
russian Federation and amendments to certain legislative acts of the russian Federation: Federal law from 30.11.2011 no. 342-Fl (in red. on 01.07.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
11. o social’noj zashchite grazhdan, podvergshihsya vozdejstviyu radiacii vsledstvie katastrofy na Chernobyl’skoj aehS : zakon ros. Federacii ot 15.05.1991 № 1244-1 (red. ot 30.10.2017) [on the social protection of citizens exposed to radiation due to the Chernobyl disaster : the law of the russian Federation from 15.05.1991 no. 1244-1 (in red. on 30.10.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
12. o strahovyh pensiyah : feder. zakon ot 28.12.2013 № 400-FZ (red. ot 28.12.2017) [on insurance pensions: Federal law from 28.12.2013 no. 400-Fl (in red. on 28.12.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
13. ob otkaze v prinyatii k rassmotreniyu zhaloby grazhdanina Klimovicha aleksandra Ivanovicha na narushenie ego konstitucionnyh prav chast’yu tret’ej stat’i 2 Zakona rossijskoj Federacii «o pensionnom obespechenii lic, prohodivshih voennuyu sluzhbu, sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe, organah po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskih sredstv i psihotropnyh veshchestv, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, i ih semej» : opredelenie Konstitucionnogo Suda ros. Federacii ot 05.07.2011 № 863-o-o [on the refusal to accept the complaint of citizen Klimovich alexander Ivanovich for violation of his constitutional rights by the third part of article 2 of the law of the russian Federation «on the provision of pensions for persons who passed military service, service in internal affairs bodies, the State Fire Service, the bodies controlling the traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, institutions and bodies of the penal system, and their families» : the definition of the russian Federation from 05.07.2011 no. 863-o-o]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
14. ob utverzhdenii Instrukcii o poryadke primeneniya Polozheniya o sluzhbe v organah vnutrennih del rossijskoj Federacii v uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy : prikaz Minyusta rossii ot 06.06.2005 № 76 (red. ot 12.12.2013) [on the approval of the Instruction on the procedure for the application of the regulations on Service in the Internal affairs agencies of the russian Federation in the Institutions and Bodies of the Penal System : order of the Ministry of Justice of the russian Federation from 06.06.2005 no. 76 (in red on 12.12.2013). access from the reference legal system
«ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
15. ob utverzhdenii perechnej dolzhnostej, predpriyatij, uchrezhdenij, organizacij ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, sluzhba v kotoryh zaschityvaetsya v vyslugu let dlya naznacheniya pensii na l’gotnyh usloviyah : prikaz Minyusta rossii ot 01.12.2005
№ 233 (red. ot 18.10.2017) [on the approval of lists of posts, enterprises, institutions, organizations of the penal system, the service in which is included in the length of service for the purpose of granting a pension on preferential terms : order of the Ministry of Justice of the russian Federation from 01.12.2005 no. 233 (in red. on 18.10.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
16. ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya o voenno-vrachebnoj ehkspertize : postanovlenie Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 04.07.2013 № 565 (red. ot 30.03.2017) [on the approval of the regulations on military medical examination : government Decision from 04.07.2013 no. 565 (in red. on 30.03.2017). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
17. ob uchrezhdeniyah i organah, ispolnyayushchih ugolovnye nakazaniya v vide lisheniya svobody : zakon ros. Federacii ot 21.07.1993 № 5473-1 (red. ot 28.12.2016) [on institutions and bodies that carry out criminal penalties in the form of deprivation of liberty : the law of the russian Federation from 21.07.1993 no. 5473-1 (in red. on 28.12.2016). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
18. osnovnye pokazateli deyatel’nosti ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy (yanvar’–dekabr’ 2017 g.) : inform.-analit. sb.
– Main indicators of the penal system (January–December 2017) : information-analytical collection. tver, 2018. 393 p. (In russ.).
2. Demin V. M. Profilaktika pravonarushenij sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy : avtoref. dis. … kand. yurid. nauk [Prevention of offenses committed by employees of the penal system : the author’s abstract of the diss. ... PhD. in law]. Moscow, 2007. 26 p. (In russ.).
3. Ivanova V. V., Sokolov n. a. aktual’nye voprosy pensionnogo obespecheniya sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy [topical issues of pension provision for employees of the penitentiary system]. aktual’nye voprosy kadrovoj raboty, social’noj i pravovoj zashchity sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy rossii : sb. materialov nauch.-prakt. seminara (g. Vologda, 17 aprelya 2017 g.) – actual issues of personnel work, social and legal protection of the staff of the russian penal system : a collection of materials of the scientific and practical seminar (Vologda, april 17, 2017). Vologda, 2017. P. 71–75. (In russ.).
4. Muhtarova e. a. Social’naya zashchita sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy [Social protection of the penitentiary system staff]. aktual’nye voprosy kadrovoj raboty, social’noj i pravovoj zashchity sotrudnikov ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy rossii : sb. materialov nauch.-prakt. seminara (g. Vologda, 17 aprelya 2017 g.) – actual issues of personnel work, social and legal protection of the staff of the russian penal system : a collection of materials of the scientific and practical seminar (Vologda, april 17, 2017). Vologda, 2017. P. 102–109. (In russ.).
5. o vnesenii proekta federal’nogo zakona «o sluzhbe v ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sisteme rossijskoj Federacii» : pis’mo Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 01.02.2018 № 845p-P4 [on the Introduction of the Draft Federal law «on Service in the Penitentiary System of the russian Federation» : a letter by the government of the russian Federation from 01.02.2018 no. 845p-P4]. availabel at: https://legal.report/uploads/doc/2/379630-7_02022018_0120032836-1.pdf (accessed 20.03.2018). (In russ.).
6. o pensionnom obespechenii voennosluzhashchih, lic nachal’stvuyushchego i ryadovogo sostava organov vnutrennih del, Sledstvennogo komiteta respubliki Belarus’, gosudarstvennogo komiteta sudebnyh ehkspertiz respubliki Belarus’, organov i podrazdelenij po chrezvychajnym situaciyam i organov finansovyh rassledovanij : zakon respubliki Belarus’ ot 17.12.1992 № 2050-XII (red. ot 09.01.2017, s izm. ot 31.12.2017) [on pension provision for servicemen, officers and officers of the internal affairs bodies, the Investigative Committee of the republic of Belarus, the State Committee of Forensic expertise of the republic of Belarus, emergency agencies and units and financial investigation bodies : law of the republic of Belarus from 17.12.1992 no. 2050-XII (in red. on 09.01.2017, as amended on 31.12.2017). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
7. o pensionnom obespechenii lic, prohodivshih voennuyu sluzhbu, sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe, organah po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskih sredstv i psihotropnyh veshchestv, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, vojskah nacional’noj gvardii rossijskoj Federacii, i ih semej : zakon ros. Federacii ot 12.02.1993 № 4468-1 (red. ot 01.07.2017) [on the provision of pensions for persons who have completed military service, service in the internal affairs agencies, the State Fire Service, the bodies responsible for controlling the circulation of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, institutions and bodies of the penal system, the troops of the national guard of the russian Federation, and their families : the law of russian Federation from 12.02.1993 no. 4468-1 (in red. on 01.07.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
8. o poryadke ischisleniya vyslugi let, naznacheniya i vyplaty pensij i posobij voennosluzhashchim oficerskogo sostava, praporshchikam, michmanam, serzhantam i starshinam, soldatam i matrosam, prohodyashchim voennuyu sluzhbu po kontraktu, licam nachal’stvuyushchego i ryadovogo sostava Sledstvennogo komiteta, gosudarstvennogo komiteta sudebnyh ehkspertiz, organov vnutrennih del, organov i podrazdelenij po chrezvychajnym situaciyam, organov finansovyh rassledovanij i chlenam ih semej : postanovlenie Soveta ministrov respubliki Belarus’ ot 05.07.1993
№ 432 (v red. ot 04.10.2017) [on the procedure for calculating the length of service, the appointment and payment of pensions and allowances to military officers of the officer corps, warrant officers, sergeants, soldiers and sailors of military service under contract, officers of the Investigative Committee, the State Committee of Forensic expertise, bodies Ministry of Internal affairs, bodies and departments for emergency situations, financial investigation bodies and members of their families: resolution of the Council of Ministers of the republic of Belarus from 05.07.1993 no. 432 (in red. on 04.10.2017)]. availabel at: https://base.spinform.ru/show_doc.fwx?rgn=23776 (accessed 01.02.2018). (In russ.).
9. o poryadke ischisleniya vyslugi let, naznacheniya i vyplaty pensij, kompensacij i posobij licam, prohodivshim voennuyu sluzhbu v kachestve oficerov, praporshchikov, michmanov i voennosluzhashchih sverhsrochnoj sluzhby ili po kontraktu v kachestve soldat, matrosov, serzhantov i starshin libo sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, federal’noj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhby, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, vojskah nacional’noj gvardii rossijskoj Federacii, i ih sem’yam v rossijskoj Federacii : postanovlenie Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 22.09.1993 № 941 (red. ot 16.08.2017) [on the procedure for calculating the length of service, the appointment and payment of pensions, compensation and benefits to persons who have served as officers, ensigns, warrant officers and servicemen of extra-long service or as contract soldiers, sailors, sergeants and foremen, or service in internal affairs bodies, the federal fire service of the State Fire Service, the institutions and bodies of the penal system, the troops of the national guard of the russian Federation, and their families in the russian Federation : decree russian Federation from 22.09.1993 no. 941 (in red. on 16.08.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
10. o sluzhbe v organah vnutrennih del rossijskoj Federacii i vnesenii izmenenij v otdel’nye zakonodatel’nye akty rossijskoj Federacii : feder. zakon ot 30.11.2011 № 342-FZ (red. ot 01.07.2017) [on the service in the internal affairs bodies of the
russian Federation and amendments to certain legislative acts of the russian Federation: Federal law from 30.11.2011 no. 342-Fl (in red. on 01.07.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
11. o social’noj zashchite grazhdan, podvergshihsya vozdejstviyu radiacii vsledstvie katastrofy na Chernobyl’skoj aehS : zakon ros. Federacii ot 15.05.1991 № 1244-1 (red. ot 30.10.2017) [on the social protection of citizens exposed to radiation due to the Chernobyl disaster : the law of the russian Federation from 15.05.1991 no. 1244-1 (in red. on 30.10.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
12. o strahovyh pensiyah : feder. zakon ot 28.12.2013 № 400-FZ (red. ot 28.12.2017) [on insurance pensions: Federal law from 28.12.2013 no. 400-Fl (in red. on 28.12.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
13. ob otkaze v prinyatii k rassmotreniyu zhaloby grazhdanina Klimovicha aleksandra Ivanovicha na narushenie ego konstitucionnyh prav chast’yu tret’ej stat’i 2 Zakona rossijskoj Federacii «o pensionnom obespechenii lic, prohodivshih voennuyu sluzhbu, sluzhbu v organah vnutrennih del, gosudarstvennoj protivopozharnoj sluzhbe, organah po kontrolyu za oborotom narkoticheskih sredstv i psihotropnyh veshchestv, uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, i ih semej» : opredelenie Konstitucionnogo Suda ros. Federacii ot 05.07.2011 № 863-o-o [on the refusal to accept the complaint of citizen Klimovich alexander Ivanovich for violation of his constitutional rights by the third part of article 2 of the law of the russian Federation «on the provision of pensions for persons who passed military service, service in internal affairs bodies, the State Fire Service, the bodies controlling the traffic in narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, institutions and bodies of the penal system, and their families» : the definition of the russian Federation from 05.07.2011 no. 863-o-o]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
14. ob utverzhdenii Instrukcii o poryadke primeneniya Polozheniya o sluzhbe v organah vnutrennih del rossijskoj Federacii v uchrezhdeniyah i organah ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy : prikaz Minyusta rossii ot 06.06.2005 № 76 (red. ot 12.12.2013) [on the approval of the Instruction on the procedure for the application of the regulations on Service in the Internal affairs agencies of the russian Federation in the Institutions and Bodies of the Penal System : order of the Ministry of Justice of the russian Federation from 06.06.2005 no. 76 (in red on 12.12.2013). access from the reference legal system
«ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
15. ob utverzhdenii perechnej dolzhnostej, predpriyatij, uchrezhdenij, organizacij ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy, sluzhba v kotoryh zaschityvaetsya v vyslugu let dlya naznacheniya pensii na l’gotnyh usloviyah : prikaz Minyusta rossii ot 01.12.2005
№ 233 (red. ot 18.10.2017) [on the approval of lists of posts, enterprises, institutions, organizations of the penal system, the service in which is included in the length of service for the purpose of granting a pension on preferential terms : order of the Ministry of Justice of the russian Federation from 01.12.2005 no. 233 (in red. on 18.10.2017)]. access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
16. ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya o voenno-vrachebnoj ehkspertize : postanovlenie Pravitel’stva ros. Federacii ot 04.07.2013 № 565 (red. ot 30.03.2017) [on the approval of the regulations on military medical examination : government Decision from 04.07.2013 no. 565 (in red. on 30.03.2017). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
17. ob uchrezhdeniyah i organah, ispolnyayushchih ugolovnye nakazaniya v vide lisheniya svobody : zakon ros. Federacii ot 21.07.1993 № 5473-1 (red. ot 28.12.2016) [on institutions and bodies that carry out criminal penalties in the form of deprivation of liberty : the law of the russian Federation from 21.07.1993 no. 5473-1 (in red. on 28.12.2016). access from the reference legal system «ConsultantPlus». (In russ.).
18. osnovnye pokazateli deyatel’nosti ugolovno-ispolnitel’noj sistemy (yanvar’–dekabr’ 2017 g.) : inform.-analit. sb.
– Main indicators of the penal system (January–December 2017) : information-analytical collection. tver, 2018. 393 p. (In russ.).
